
so i've finally had time to digest the two-hour
American Idol mega-finale and here are my thoughts:
-
Bucky sounded worlds better than he ever did on the show!! he harmonized with
Daughtry and he didn't make it stink!! i don't know if he's gonna make it in the biz, but if he continues his good sounds into the tour, perhaps some country start-up label will take a "Buck" shot!
-
Paris sounded worse this time around. her duet with
Al Jarreau was butt. and her sound was so inconsistent, it seems like she forgot how to sing into a microphone.
- speaking of microphones, why does
Carrie Underwood insist on hiding behind hers? i'll admit, i didn't watch last season's
AI (it took me two whole years to recover from
Aiken!), but i don't get her at all. i heard her version of "Alone" from the competition and i did think that rocked, but she just doesn't give me any emotion when she sings. now that i've seen her perform a little, i realize that
Kellie Pickler was probably the victim of
Carrie Underwood backlash. who needs two American Idols in a row who sound pretty as a peach, but look completely snoozapalooza when they sing? is it too late to vote for
Bo Bice?
-
Elliot +
Mary J. =
HEAVEN!!! seriously, the second i heard Elliot start "One", i knew that Mary was going to be his partner - she has been riding the
1 Train ever since the Tsunami, people!! i think that Elliot was too polite or in awe to truly take his place with Mary, but once he did - magic!! if Elliot had chosen "One" or any song with more rock sensabilities during the competition, i think he would have stolen some
Daughtry fans who figured a)he's married and b)he's every other girl's favorite. Elliot fared better than any of the Idols,
Soul Patrol included!! everything he sang sounded great and i am sure we will be hearing from him soon.
-
Katharine +
Meat Loaf =
Presto Strange-o!! if you need proof that Katharine cannot act, look no further than her mini-musical with the Meat. first off, Meat sounded terrible!! what happened to him?? i am hoping and praying that
Bat Out of Hell III has some juice in it, but the prospects are not good. second, Katharine was so disgusted with him, she couldn't even look him in the eye when she sang with him. she just seemed too snobby. McPheever broken!
-
Daughtry +
Live =
Sweet!! i actually like
Live a lot (brides to be, think of the acoustic version of "Heaven" for your father-and-daughter dance or PowerPoint slide show!) and thought that they sounded great together. i thought
Ed hogged the mike a bit - folks
were here to see
Chris and their thunderous cheers proved it. i'm just glad that Daughtry got to reconnect with his fans in time to save him from obscurity. but go easy on the singing, boy - at that rate, your voice will never survive the tour!
-
Soul Patrol +
Toni B. =
BARF!! you ever see the episode of
Degrassi Junior High when
Kathleen has to have her
Quest for the Best teammates over her house to watch the tape of the returning champions and Kathleen's mother embarasses everyone because she's stone cold
drunk??
that's what it felt like to watch
Toni Braxton try to sex her way into "the ghetto" with
Taylor.
Bedroom-eyes McPhee, learn from this:
this is what happens when you rely on sex rather than talent.
CLAY!!!!!!!!
you have rendered me speechless. while i was
thrilled to see you perform again, after your self-imposed sexile, the look was gross!! you look gross!! and i love you enough to tell you this!! what is going on? do you need help? i will help you, but you need to ask for it. seriously, i don't know where this train is heading, but it is not good. Clay, just come out already and become the
George Michael/Elton John lovechild the world has been waiting for!!!!! the world can no longer be denied your gift!!
and while you're at it, quit asking for the
"Eddie Furlong" at the salon!!

speaking of
Eddie Furlong, what the
hell is this?!?!?!? this just came out last year!!!!